groupbasedpolicy/src/test/java/org/opendaylight/groupbasedpolicy/renderer/RendererManagerTest.java

   1 /*
   2  * Copyright (c) 2016 Cisco Systems, Inc. and others. All rights reserved.
   3  *
   4  * This program and the accompanying materials are made available under the
   5  * terms of the Eclipse Public License v1.0 which accompanies this distribution,
   6  * and is available at http://www.eclipse.org/legal/epl-v10.html
   7  */
   8
   9 package org.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.renderer;
  10
  11 import static org.junit.Assert.assertEquals;
  12 import static org.junit.Assert.assertFalse;
  13 import static org.junit.Assert.assertTrue;
  14
  15 import java.util.Collections;
  16 import java.util.Set;
  17
  18 import org.junit.Before;
  19 import org.junit.Test;
  20 import org.junit.runner.RunWith;
  21 import org.mockito.Mock;
  22 import org.mockito.Mockito;
  23 import org.mockito.runners.MockitoJUnitRunner;
  24 import org.opendaylight.controller.md.sal.binding.api.DataBroker;
  25 import org.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.forwarding.NetworkDomainAugmentorRegistryImpl;
  26 import org.opendaylight.yang.gen.v1.urn.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.base_endpoint.rev160427.EndpointLocations;
  27 import org.opendaylight.yang.gen.v1.urn.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.base_endpoint.rev160427.EndpointLocationsBuilder;
  28 import org.opendaylight.yang.gen.v1.urn.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.base_endpoint.rev160427.Endpoints;
  29 import org.opendaylight.yang.gen.v1.urn.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.base_endpoint.rev160427.EndpointsBuilder;
  30 import org.opendaylight.yang.gen.v1.urn.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.base_endpoint.rev160427.endpoint.locations.AddressEndpointLocation;
  31 import org.opendaylight.yang.gen.v1.urn.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.base_endpoint.rev160427.endpoints.AddressEndpointsBuilder;
  32 import org.opendaylight.yang.gen.v1.urn.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.base_endpoint.rev160427.endpoints.address.endpoints.AddressEndpoint;
  33 import org.opendaylight.yang.gen.v1.urn.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.base_endpoint.rev160427.has.absolute.location.absolute.location.location.type.InternalLocationCase;
  34 import org.opendaylight.yang.gen.v1.urn.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.base_endpoint.rev160427.has.absolute.location.absolute.location.location.type.InternalLocationCaseBuilder;
  35 import org.opendaylight.yang.gen.v1.urn.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.common.rev140421.ContractId;
  36 import org.opendaylight.yang.gen.v1.urn.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.common.rev140421.EndpointGroupId;
  37 import org.opendaylight.yang.gen.v1.urn.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.common.rev140421.RuleName;
  38 import org.opendaylight.yang.gen.v1.urn.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.common.rev140421.SubjectName;
  39 import org.opendaylight.yang.gen.v1.urn.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.policy.rev140421.Tenants;
  40 import org.opendaylight.yang.gen.v1.urn.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.renderer.rev151103.EndpointPolicyParticipation;
  41 import org.opendaylight.yang.gen.v1.urn.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.renderer.rev151103.has.peer.endpoints.PeerEndpointKey;
  42 import org.opendaylight.yang.gen.v1.urn.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.renderer.rev151103.has.rule.group.with.renderer.endpoint.participation.RuleGroupWithRendererEndpointParticipation;
  43 import org.opendaylight.yang.gen.v1.urn.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.renderer.rev151103.renderers.renderer.renderer.policy.configuration.renderer.endpoints.RendererEndpointKey;
  44 import org.opendaylight.yang.gen.v1.urn.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.resolved.policy.rev150828.ResolvedPolicies;
  45 import org.opendaylight.yang.gen.v1.urn.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.resolved.policy.rev150828.ResolvedPoliciesBuilder;
  46 import org.opendaylight.yang.gen.v1.urn.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.resolved.policy.rev150828.has.resolved.rules.ResolvedRule;
  47 import org.opendaylight.yang.gen.v1.urn.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.resolved.policy.rev150828.resolved.policies.ResolvedPolicy;
  48 import org.opendaylight.yang.gen.v1.urn.opendaylight.groupbasedpolicy.resolved.policy.rev150828.resolved.policies.resolved.policy.policy.rule.group.with.endpoint.constraints.PolicyRuleGroup;
  49 import org.opendaylight.yangtools.yang.binding.InstanceIdentifier;
  50
  51 import com.google.common.collect.ImmutableList;
  52 import com.google.common.collect.ImmutableTable;
  53
  54 @RunWith(MockitoJUnitRunner.class)
  55 public class RendererManagerTest {
  56
  57     private static final EndpointGroupId EPG_BLUE = new EndpointGroupId("blue_epg");
  58     private static final EndpointGroupId EPG_PURPLE = new EndpointGroupId("purple_epg");
  59     private static final EndpointGroupId EPG_RED = new EndpointGroupId("red_epg");
  60     private static final EndpointGroupId EPG_GREY = new EndpointGroupId("grey_epg");
  61     private static final ContractId CONTRACT_1 = new ContractId("contract_1");
  62     private static final SubjectName SUBJECT_1 = new SubjectName("subject_1");
  63     private static final RuleName RULE_1 = new RuleName("rule_1");
  64     private static final ContractId CONTRACT_2 = new ContractId("contract_2");
  65     private static final SubjectName SUBJECT_2 = new SubjectName("subject_2");
  66     private static final String ADR_1 = "adr_1";
  67     private static final String ADR_2 = "adr_2";
  68     private static final String ADR_3 = "adr_3";
  69     private static final String ADR_4 = "adr_4";
  70     private static final InstanceIdentifier<?> NODE_PATH_1 = InstanceIdentifier.create(Tenants.class);
  71     private static final InternalLocationCase REG_LOC_NODE_PATH_1 =
  72             new InternalLocationCaseBuilder().setInternalNode(NODE_PATH_1).build();
  73
  74     @Mock
  75     private DataBroker dataProvider;
  76     @Mock
  77     private NetworkDomainAugmentorRegistryImpl netDomainAugmentorRegistry;
  78
  79     private RendererManager rendererManager;
  80
  81     @Before
  82     public void init() {
  83         Mockito.when(netDomainAugmentorRegistry.getEndpointAugmentors()).thenReturn(Collections.emptySet());
  84         rendererManager = new RendererManager(dataProvider, netDomainAugmentorRegistry);
  85     }
  86
  87     /**
  88      * EP1--EPG_BLUE---SUBJECT_1---(P)EPG_PURPLE--EP2
  89      */
  90     @Test
  91     public void testResolveRendererPolicyForEndpoint_onePolicy() {
  92         ResolvedRule rule1 = TestDataFactory.defaultResolvedRule(RULE_1).build();
  93         PolicyRuleGroup ruleGrp1 = TestDataFactory.defaultPolicyRuleGrp(CONTRACT_1, SUBJECT_1, rule1).build();
  94         ResolvedPolicy resolvedPolicy = TestDataFactory.defaultResolvedPolicy(EPG_BLUE, EPG_PURPLE, ruleGrp1).build();
  95         ResolvedPolicies resolvedPolicies =
  96                 new ResolvedPoliciesBuilder().setResolvedPolicy(ImmutableList.of(resolvedPolicy)).build();
  97         rendererManager.resolvedPoliciesUpdated(resolvedPolicies);
  98
  99         AddressEndpoint ep1 = TestDataFactory.defaultAdrEp(ADR_1, EPG_BLUE).build();
 100         AddressEndpoint ep2 = TestDataFactory.defaultAdrEp(ADR_2, EPG_PURPLE).build();
 101         Endpoints endpoints = new EndpointsBuilder()
 102             .setAddressEndpoints(new AddressEndpointsBuilder().setAddressEndpoint(ImmutableList.of(ep1, ep2)).build())
 103             .build();
 104         rendererManager.endpointsUpdated(endpoints);
 105
 106         AddressEndpointLocation ep1Loc = TestDataFactory.defaultAdrEpLoc(ep1.getKey(), REG_LOC_NODE_PATH_1).build();
 107         AddressEndpointLocation ep2Loc = TestDataFactory.defaultAdrEpLoc(ep2.getKey(), REG_LOC_NODE_PATH_1).build();
 108         EndpointLocations endpointLocations =
 109                 new EndpointLocationsBuilder().setAddressEndpointLocation(ImmutableList.of(ep1Loc, ep2Loc)).build();
 110         rendererManager.endpointLocationsUpdated(endpointLocations);
 111
 112         RendererConfigurationBuilder rendererPolicyBuilder = new RendererConfigurationBuilder();
 113         rendererManager.resolveRendererConfigForEndpoint(ep1, rendererPolicyBuilder);
 114         ImmutableTable<RendererEndpointKey, PeerEndpointKey, Set<RuleGroupWithRendererEndpointParticipation>> policiesByEpAndPeerEp =
 115                 rendererPolicyBuilder.getPoliciesByEpAndPeerEp();
 116         assertFalse(policiesByEpAndPeerEp.isEmpty());
 117         assertTrue(rendererPolicyBuilder.getPoliciesByEpAndPeerExtEp().isEmpty());
 118         assertTrue(rendererPolicyBuilder.getPoliciesByEpAndPeerExtConEp().isEmpty());
 119         assertEquals(1, policiesByEpAndPeerEp.rowKeySet().size());
 120         assertEquals(1, policiesByEpAndPeerEp.columnKeySet().size());
 121         // check EP1--EPG_BLUE---SUBJECT_1---(P)EPG_PURPLE--EP2
 122         RendererEndpointKey rendererEpKey = AddressEndpointUtils.toRendererEpKey(ep1.getKey());
 123         assertEquals(rendererEpKey, policiesByEpAndPeerEp.rowKeySet().iterator().next());
 124         PeerEndpointKey peerEpKey = AddressEndpointUtils.toPeerEpKey(ep2.getKey());
 125         assertEquals(peerEpKey, policiesByEpAndPeerEp.columnKeySet().iterator().next());
 126         Set<RuleGroupWithRendererEndpointParticipation> ruleGrpsWithEpPartic =
 127                 policiesByEpAndPeerEp.get(rendererEpKey, peerEpKey);
 128         assertEquals(1, ruleGrpsWithEpPartic.size());
 129         RuleGroupWithRendererEndpointParticipation ruleGrpWithEpPartic = ruleGrpsWithEpPartic.iterator().next();
 130         assertEquals(ruleGrp1.getTenantId(), ruleGrpWithEpPartic.getTenantId());
 131         assertEquals(ruleGrp1.getContractId(), ruleGrpWithEpPartic.getContractId());
 132         assertEquals(ruleGrp1.getSubjectName(), ruleGrpWithEpPartic.getSubjectName());
 133         assertEquals(EndpointPolicyParticipation.CONSUMER, ruleGrpWithEpPartic.getRendererEndpointParticipation());
 134     }
 135
 136     /**
 137      * EP1--EPG_BLUE---SUBJECT_1---(P)EPG_PURPLE--EP2
 138      * <br>
 139      * EP3--EPG_RED----SUBJECT_1---(P)EPG_GREY--EP4
 140      */
 141     @Test
 142     public void testResolveRendererPolicyForEndpoint_onePolicyTwoUsage() {
 143         ResolvedRule rule1 = TestDataFactory.defaultResolvedRule(RULE_1).build();
 144         PolicyRuleGroup ruleGrp1 = TestDataFactory.defaultPolicyRuleGrp(CONTRACT_1, SUBJECT_1, rule1).build();
 145         ResolvedPolicy bluePurplePolicy = TestDataFactory.defaultResolvedPolicy(EPG_BLUE, EPG_PURPLE, ruleGrp1).build();
 146         ResolvedPolicy redGreyPolicy = TestDataFactory.defaultResolvedPolicy(EPG_RED, EPG_GREY, ruleGrp1).build();
 147         ResolvedPolicies resolvedPolicies = new ResolvedPoliciesBuilder()
 148             .setResolvedPolicy(ImmutableList.of(bluePurplePolicy, redGreyPolicy)).build();
 149         rendererManager.resolvedPoliciesUpdated(resolvedPolicies);
 150
 151         AddressEndpoint ep1 = TestDataFactory.defaultAdrEp(ADR_1, EPG_BLUE).build();
 152         AddressEndpoint ep2 = TestDataFactory.defaultAdrEp(ADR_2, EPG_PURPLE).build();
 153         AddressEndpoint ep3 = TestDataFactory.defaultAdrEp(ADR_3, EPG_RED).build();
 154         AddressEndpoint ep4 = TestDataFactory.defaultAdrEp(ADR_4, EPG_GREY).build();
 155         Endpoints endpoints = new EndpointsBuilder()
 156             .setAddressEndpoints(
 157                     new AddressEndpointsBuilder().setAddressEndpoint(ImmutableList.of(ep1, ep2, ep3, ep4)).build())
 158             .build();
 159         rendererManager.endpointsUpdated(endpoints);
 160
 161         AddressEndpointLocation ep1Loc = TestDataFactory.defaultAdrEpLoc(ep1.getKey(), REG_LOC_NODE_PATH_1).build();
 162         AddressEndpointLocation ep2Loc = TestDataFactory.defaultAdrEpLoc(ep2.getKey(), REG_LOC_NODE_PATH_1).build();
 163         AddressEndpointLocation ep3Loc = TestDataFactory.defaultAdrEpLoc(ep3.getKey(), REG_LOC_NODE_PATH_1).build();
 164         AddressEndpointLocation ep4Loc = TestDataFactory.defaultAdrEpLoc(ep4.getKey(), REG_LOC_NODE_PATH_1).build();
 165         EndpointLocations endpointLocations = new EndpointLocationsBuilder()
 166             .setAddressEndpointLocation(ImmutableList.of(ep1Loc, ep2Loc, ep3Loc, ep4Loc)).build();
 167         rendererManager.endpointLocationsUpdated(endpointLocations);
 168
 169         // EP1, EP3 as renderer endpoints
 170         RendererConfigurationBuilder rendererPolicyBuilder = new RendererConfigurationBuilder();
 171         rendererManager.resolveRendererConfigForEndpoint(ep1, rendererPolicyBuilder);
 172         rendererManager.resolveRendererConfigForEndpoint(ep3, rendererPolicyBuilder);
 173         ImmutableTable<RendererEndpointKey, PeerEndpointKey, Set<RuleGroupWithRendererEndpointParticipation>> policiesByEpAndPeerEp =
 174                 rendererPolicyBuilder.getPoliciesByEpAndPeerEp();
 175         assertFalse(policiesByEpAndPeerEp.isEmpty());
 176         assertTrue(rendererPolicyBuilder.getPoliciesByEpAndPeerExtEp().isEmpty());
 177         assertTrue(rendererPolicyBuilder.getPoliciesByEpAndPeerExtConEp().isEmpty());
 178         assertEquals(2, policiesByEpAndPeerEp.rowKeySet().size());
 179         assertEquals(2, policiesByEpAndPeerEp.columnKeySet().size());
 180         // check EPG_BLUE---SUBJECT_1---(P)EPG_PURPLE
 181         RendererEndpointKey ep1RendererEpKey = AddressEndpointUtils.toRendererEpKey(ep1.getKey());
 182         assertTrue(policiesByEpAndPeerEp.containsRow(ep1RendererEpKey));
 183         PeerEndpointKey ep2PeerEpKey = AddressEndpointUtils.toPeerEpKey(ep2.getKey());
 184         assertTrue(policiesByEpAndPeerEp.containsColumn(ep2PeerEpKey));
 185         Set<RuleGroupWithRendererEndpointParticipation> ep1Ep2RuleGrpsWithEpPartic =
 186                 policiesByEpAndPeerEp.get(ep1RendererEpKey, ep2PeerEpKey);
 187         assertEquals(1, ep1Ep2RuleGrpsWithEpPartic.size());
 188         RuleGroupWithRendererEndpointParticipation ruleGrp1WithEpPartic = ep1Ep2RuleGrpsWithEpPartic.iterator().next();
 189         assertEquals(ruleGrp1.getTenantId(), ruleGrp1WithEpPartic.getTenantId());
 190         assertEquals(ruleGrp1.getContractId(), ruleGrp1WithEpPartic.getContractId());
 191         assertEquals(ruleGrp1.getSubjectName(), ruleGrp1WithEpPartic.getSubjectName());
 192         assertEquals(EndpointPolicyParticipation.CONSUMER, ruleGrp1WithEpPartic.getRendererEndpointParticipation());
 193         // check EP3--EPG_RED----SUBJECT_1---(P)EPG_GREY--EP4
 194         RendererEndpointKey ep3RendererEpKey = AddressEndpointUtils.toRendererEpKey(ep3.getKey());
 195         assertTrue(policiesByEpAndPeerEp.containsRow(ep3RendererEpKey));
 196         PeerEndpointKey ep4PeerEpKey = AddressEndpointUtils.toPeerEpKey(ep4.getKey());
 197         assertTrue(policiesByEpAndPeerEp.containsColumn(ep4PeerEpKey));
 198         Set<RuleGroupWithRendererEndpointParticipation> ep3Ep4RuleGrpsWithEpPartic =
 199                 policiesByEpAndPeerEp.get(ep3RendererEpKey, ep4PeerEpKey);
 200         assertEquals(1, ep3Ep4RuleGrpsWithEpPartic.size());
 201         ruleGrp1WithEpPartic = ep3Ep4RuleGrpsWithEpPartic.iterator().next();
 202         assertEquals(ruleGrp1.getTenantId(), ruleGrp1WithEpPartic.getTenantId());
 203         assertEquals(ruleGrp1.getContractId(), ruleGrp1WithEpPartic.getContractId());
 204         assertEquals(ruleGrp1.getSubjectName(), ruleGrp1WithEpPartic.getSubjectName());
 205         assertEquals(EndpointPolicyParticipation.CONSUMER, ruleGrp1WithEpPartic.getRendererEndpointParticipation());
 206     }
 207
 208     /**
 209      * EP1--EPG_BLUE---SUBJECT_1---(P)EPG_PURPLE--EP2
 210      * <br>
 211      * EP1--EPG_RED----SUBJECT_2---(P)EPG_GREY--EP2,EP3
 212      */
 213     @Test
 214     public void testResolveRendererPolicyForEndpoint_twoPolicy() {
 215         ResolvedRule rule1 = TestDataFactory.defaultResolvedRule(RULE_1).build();
 216         PolicyRuleGroup ruleGrp1 = TestDataFactory.defaultPolicyRuleGrp(CONTRACT_1, SUBJECT_1, rule1).build();
 217         PolicyRuleGroup ruleGrp2 = TestDataFactory.defaultPolicyRuleGrp(CONTRACT_2, SUBJECT_2, rule1).build();
 218         ResolvedPolicy bluePurplePolicy = TestDataFactory.defaultResolvedPolicy(EPG_BLUE, EPG_PURPLE, ruleGrp1).build();
 219         ResolvedPolicy redGreyPolicy = TestDataFactory.defaultResolvedPolicy(EPG_RED, EPG_GREY, ruleGrp2).build();
 220         ResolvedPolicies resolvedPolicies = new ResolvedPoliciesBuilder()
 221             .setResolvedPolicy(ImmutableList.of(bluePurplePolicy, redGreyPolicy)).build();
 222         rendererManager.resolvedPoliciesUpdated(resolvedPolicies);
 223
 224         AddressEndpoint ep1 = TestDataFactory.defaultAdrEp(ADR_1, EPG_BLUE, EPG_RED).build();
 225         AddressEndpoint ep2 = TestDataFactory.defaultAdrEp(ADR_2, EPG_PURPLE, EPG_GREY).build();
 226         AddressEndpoint ep3 = TestDataFactory.defaultAdrEp(ADR_3, EPG_GREY).build();
 227         Endpoints endpoints =
 228                 new EndpointsBuilder()
 229                     .setAddressEndpoints(
 230                             new AddressEndpointsBuilder().setAddressEndpoint(ImmutableList.of(ep1, ep2, ep3)).build())
 231                     .build();
 232         rendererManager.endpointsUpdated(endpoints);
 233
 234         AddressEndpointLocation ep1Loc = TestDataFactory.defaultAdrEpLoc(ep1.getKey(), REG_LOC_NODE_PATH_1).build();
 235         AddressEndpointLocation ep2Loc = TestDataFactory.defaultAdrEpLoc(ep2.getKey(), REG_LOC_NODE_PATH_1).build();
 236         AddressEndpointLocation ep3Loc = TestDataFactory.defaultAdrEpLoc(ep3.getKey(), REG_LOC_NODE_PATH_1).build();
 237         EndpointLocations endpointLocations = new EndpointLocationsBuilder()
 238             .setAddressEndpointLocation(ImmutableList.of(ep1Loc, ep2Loc, ep3Loc)).build();
 239         rendererManager.endpointLocationsUpdated(endpointLocations);
 240
 241         // EP1 as renderer endpoint
 242         RendererConfigurationBuilder rendererPolicyBuilder = new RendererConfigurationBuilder();
 243         rendererManager.resolveRendererConfigForEndpoint(ep1, rendererPolicyBuilder);
 244         ImmutableTable<RendererEndpointKey, PeerEndpointKey, Set<RuleGroupWithRendererEndpointParticipation>> policiesByEpAndPeerEp =
 245                 rendererPolicyBuilder.getPoliciesByEpAndPeerEp();
 246         assertFalse(policiesByEpAndPeerEp.isEmpty());
 247         assertTrue(rendererPolicyBuilder.getPoliciesByEpAndPeerExtEp().isEmpty());
 248         assertTrue(rendererPolicyBuilder.getPoliciesByEpAndPeerExtConEp().isEmpty());
 249         assertEquals(1, policiesByEpAndPeerEp.rowKeySet().size());
 250         assertEquals(2, policiesByEpAndPeerEp.columnKeySet().size());
 251         // check EP1--EPG_BLUE---SUBJECT_1---(P)EPG_PURPLE--EP2
 252         // check EP1--EPG_RED----SUBJECT_2---(P)EPG_GREY--EP2
 253         RendererEndpointKey ep1RendererEpKey = AddressEndpointUtils.toRendererEpKey(ep1.getKey());
 254         assertTrue(policiesByEpAndPeerEp.containsRow(ep1RendererEpKey));
 255         PeerEndpointKey ep2PeerEpKey = AddressEndpointUtils.toPeerEpKey(ep2.getKey());
 256         assertTrue(policiesByEpAndPeerEp.containsColumn(ep2PeerEpKey));
 257         Set<RuleGroupWithRendererEndpointParticipation> ep1Ep2RuleGrpsWithEpPartic =
 258                 policiesByEpAndPeerEp.get(ep1RendererEpKey, ep2PeerEpKey);
 259         assertEquals(2, ep1Ep2RuleGrpsWithEpPartic.size());
 260         assertTrue(ep1Ep2RuleGrpsWithEpPartic.contains(RendererConfigurationBuilder
 261             .toRuleGroupWithRendererEndpointParticipation(ruleGrp1.getKey(), EndpointPolicyParticipation.CONSUMER)));
 262         assertTrue(ep1Ep2RuleGrpsWithEpPartic.contains(RendererConfigurationBuilder
 263             .toRuleGroupWithRendererEndpointParticipation(ruleGrp2.getKey(), EndpointPolicyParticipation.CONSUMER)));
 264         // check EP1--EPG_RED----SUBJECT_2---(P)EPG_GREY--EP3
 265         PeerEndpointKey ep3PeerEpKey = AddressEndpointUtils.toPeerEpKey(ep3.getKey());
 266         assertTrue(policiesByEpAndPeerEp.containsColumn(ep3PeerEpKey));
 267         Set<RuleGroupWithRendererEndpointParticipation> ep1Ep3RuleGrpsWithEpPartic =
 268                 policiesByEpAndPeerEp.get(ep1RendererEpKey, ep3PeerEpKey);
 269         assertEquals(1, ep1Ep3RuleGrpsWithEpPartic.size());
 270         assertTrue(ep1Ep3RuleGrpsWithEpPartic.contains(RendererConfigurationBuilder
 271             .toRuleGroupWithRendererEndpointParticipation(ruleGrp2.getKey(), EndpointPolicyParticipation.CONSUMER)));
 272     }
 273
 274 }