csit/suites/netconf/MDSAL/northbound.robot

   1 *** Settings ***
   2 Documentation     Metconf MDSAL Northbound test suite.
   3 ...
   4 ...               Copyright (c) 2015 Cisco Systems, Inc. and others. All rights reserved.
   5 ...
   6 ...               This program and the accompanying materials are made available under the
   7 ...               terms of the Eclipse Public License v1.0 which accompanies this distribution,
   8 ...               and is available at http://www.eclipse.org/legal/epl-v10.html
   9 ...
  10 ...
  11 ...               The request produced by test cases "Get Config Running", "Get Config Running
  12 ...               To Confirm No_Edit Before Commit", "Get Config Running To Confirm Delete
  13 ...               After Commit" and "Get Config Candidate To Confirm Discard" all use the same
  14 ...               message id ("empty") for their requests. This is possible because the
  15 ...               requests produced by this suite are strictly serialized. The RFC 6241 does
  16 ...               not state that these IDs are unique, it only requires that each ID used is
  17 ...               "XML attribute normalized" if the client wants it to be returned unmodified.
  18 ...               The RFC specifically says that "the content of this attribute is not
  19 ...               interpreted in any way, it only is stored to be returned with the reply to
  20 ...               the request. The reuse of the "empty" string for the 4 test cases was chosen
  21 ...               for simplicity.
  22 ...
  23 ...               TODO: Change the 4 testcases to use unique message IDs.
  24 Suite Setup       Setup_Everything
  25 Suite Teardown    Teardown_Everything
  26 Test Setup        SetupUtils.Setup_Test_With_Logging_And_Without_Fast_Failing
  27 Library           RequestsLibrary
  28 Library           SSHLibrary
  29 Resource          ${CURDIR}/../../../libraries/FailFast.robot
  30 Resource          ${CURDIR}/../../../libraries/SetupUtils.robot
  31 Resource          ${CURDIR}/../../../libraries/SSHKeywords.robot
  32 Resource          ${CURDIR}/../../../libraries/Utils.robot
  33 Variables         ${CURDIR}/../../../variables/Variables.py
  34
  35 *** Variables ***
  36 ${datadir}        ${CURDIR}/../../../variables/netconf/MDSAL
  37 ${dataext}        msg
  38 ${ssh_netconf_pid}    -1
  39
  40 *** Test Cases ***
  41 Connect_To_ODL_Netconf
  42     [Documentation]    Connect to ODL Netconf and fail if that is not possible.
  43     Create_ODL_Netconf_Connection
  44     Open_ODL_Netconf_Connection
  45
  46 Get_Config_Running
  47     [Documentation]    Make sure the configuration has only the default elements in it.
  48     Check_Test_Objects_Not_Present_In_Config    get-config
  49
  50 Missing_Message_ID_Attribute
  51     [Documentation]    Check that messages with missing "message-ID" attribute are rejected with the correct error (RFC 6241, section 4.1).
  52     Perform_Test    missing-attr
  53
  54 Additional_Attributes_In_Message
  55     [Documentation]    Check that additional attributes in messages are returned properly (RFC 6241, sections 4.1 and 4.2).
  56     ${reply}=    Load_And_Send_Message    additional-attr
  57     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${reply}    xmlns="urn:ietf:params:xml:ns:netconf:base:1.0"
  58     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${reply}    message-id="1"
  59     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${reply}    attribute="something"
  60     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${reply}    additional="otherthing"
  61     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${reply}    xmlns:prefix="http://www.example.com/my-schema-example.html"
  62
  63 Edit_Config_Modules_Merge
  64     [Documentation]    Request a "merge" operation adding an element in candidate configuration and check the reply.
  65     Perform_Test    config-modules-merge-1
  66
  67 Get_Config_Running_To_Confirm_No_Edit_Before_Commit
  68     [Documentation]    Make sure the running configuration is still unchanged as the change was not commited yet.
  69     Check_Test_Objects_Not_Present_In_Config    get-config-no-edit-before-commit
  70
  71 Commit_Edit
  72     [Documentation]    Commit the change and check the reply.
  73     Perform_Test    commit-edit
  74
  75 name0_In_Config_Running_To_Confirm_Edit_After_Commit
  76     [Documentation]    Check that the change is now in the configuration.
  77     ${reply}=    Load_And_Send_Message    get-config-edit-after-commit
  78     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${reply}    <name>name0</name>
  79
  80 name0_In_Config_Modules_Via_Restconf
  81     [Documentation]    Check that the change is also visible through Restconf.
  82     ${data}=    Utils.Get_Data_From_URI    config    config:modules    headers=${ACCEPT_XML}
  83     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${data}    <name>name0</name>
  84
  85 Terminate_Connection_Gracefully
  86     [Documentation]    Close the session and disconnect.
  87     Close_ODL_Netconf_Connection_Gracefully
  88
  89 name0_In_Config_Modules_Via_Restconf_After_Disconnect
  90     [Documentation]    Check that the change is still visible through Restconf after Netconf disconnect.
  91     ${data}=    Utils.Get_Data_From_URI    config    config:modules    headers=${ACCEPT_XML}
  92     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${data}    <name>name0</name>
  93
  94 Reconnect_To_ODL_Netconf_After_Graceful_Session_End
  95     [Documentation]    Reconnect to ODL Netconf and fail if that is not possible.
  96     Open_ODL_Netconf_Connection
  97
  98 name0_In_Config_Running_After_Reconnect
  99     [Documentation]    Check that the change is now in the configuration.
 100     ${reply}=    Load_And_Send_Message    get-config-edit-after-commit
 101     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${reply}    <name>name0</name>
 102
 103 name0_In_Config_Modules_Via_Restconf_After_Reconnect
 104     [Documentation]    Check that the change is still visible through Restconf after Netconf reconnect.
 105     ${data}=    Utils.Get_Data_From_URI    config    config:modules    headers=${ACCEPT_XML}
 106     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${data}    <name>name0</name>
 107
 108 Edit_Config_Modules_Create_Shall_Fail_Now
 109     [Documentation]    Request a "create" operation of an element that already exists and check that it fails with the correct error (RFC 6241, section 7.2, operation "create").
 110     Perform_Test    config-modules-create
 111
 112 Delete_Modules
 113     [Documentation]    Delete the created element from the candidate configuration and check the reply.
 114     Perform_Test    config-modules-delete
 115
 116 Get_Config_Running_To_Confirm_No_Delete_Before_Commit
 117     [Documentation]    Make sure the element is still present in the running configuration as the delete command was not committed yet.
 118     ${reply}=    Load_And_Send_Message    get-config-no-delete-before-commit
 119     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${reply}    <name>name0</name>
 120
 121 Commit_Delete
 122     [Documentation]    Commit the deletion of the element and check the reply.
 123     Perform_Test    commit-delete
 124
 125 Get_Config_Running_To_Confirm_Delete_After_Commit
 126     [Documentation]    Check that the element is gone.
 127     Check_Test_Objects_Not_Present_In_Config    get-config-delete-after-commit
 128
 129 Restconf_Get_Modules_Shall_Return_404
 130     [Documentation]    Check that "Not Found" is returned when Restconf is asked for the deleted element.
 131     ${response}=    RequestsLibrary.Get    config    config:modules    ${ACCEPT_XML}
 132     BuiltIn.Should_Be_Equal_As_Strings    404    ${response.status_code}
 133
 134 Commit_No_Transaction
 135     [Documentation]    Attempt to perform "commit" when there are no changes in the candidate configuration and check that it fails with the correct error.
 136     Test_Commit_With_No_Transactions
 137
 138 Edit_Config_Another_Modules_Merge_For_Discard
 139     [Documentation]    Create an element to be discarded and check the reply.
 140     Perform_Test    config-modules-merge-2
 141
 142 Get_And_Check_Config_Candidate_For_Discard
 143     [Documentation]    Check that the element to be discarded is present in the candidate configuration.
 144     ${reply}=    Load_And_Send_Message    get-config-candidate
 145     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${reply}    <name>name1</name>
 146     BuiltIn.Should_Not_Contain    ${reply}    name0
 147
 148 Discard_Changes_Using_Discard_Request
 149     [Documentation]    Ask the server to discard the candidate and check the reply.
 150     Perform_Test    commit-discard
 151
 152 Get_And_Check_Config_Candidate_To_Confirm_Discard
 153     [Documentation]    Check that the element was really discarded.
 154     Check_Test_Objects_Not_Present_In_Config    get-config-candidate-discard
 155
 156 Edit_Config_Modules_Multiple_Modules_Merge_1
 157     [Documentation]    Create the element with "name2" subelement again and check the reply.
 158     Perform_Test    merge-multiple-1
 159
 160 Edit_Config_Modules_Multiple_Modules_Merge_2
 161     [Documentation]    Add a "name3" subelement to the element and check the reply.
 162     Perform_Test    merge-multiple-2
 163
 164 Edit_Config_Modules_Multiple_Modules_Merge_3
 165     [Documentation]    Add a "name4" subelement to the element and check the reply.
 166     Perform_Test    merge-multiple-3
 167
 168 Commit_Multiple_Modules_Merge
 169     [Documentation]    Commit the changes and check the reply.
 170     Perform_Test    merge-multiple-commit
 171
 172 name2_name3_name4_In_Running_Config
 173     [Documentation]    Check that the 3 subelements are now present in the running configuration.
 174     ${reply}=    Load_And_Send_Message    merge-multiple-check
 175     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${reply}    <name>name2</name>
 176     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${reply}    <name>name3</name>
 177     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${reply}    <name>name4</name>
 178
 179 name2_name3_name4_In_Config_Modules_Via_Restconf
 180     [Documentation]    Check that the 3 subelements are visible via Restconf.
 181     ${data}=    Utils.Get_Data_From_URI    config    config:modules    headers=${ACCEPT_XML}
 182     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${data}    <name>name2</name>
 183     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${data}    <name>name3</name>
 184     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${data}    <name>name4</name>
 185
 186 Abort_Connection_To_Simulate_Session_Failure
 187     [Documentation]    Simulate session failure by disconnecting without terminating the session.
 188     Abort_ODL_Netconf_Connection
 189
 190 name2_name3_name4_In_Config_Modules_Via_Restconf_After_Session_Fail
 191     [Documentation]    Check that the 3 subelements are visible via Restconf.
 192     ${data}=    Utils.Get_Data_From_URI    config    config:modules    headers=${ACCEPT_XML}
 193     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${data}    <name>name2</name>
 194     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${data}    <name>name3</name>
 195     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${data}    <name>name4</name>
 196
 197 Reconnect_To_ODL_Netconf_After_Session_Failure
 198     [Documentation]    Reconnect to ODL Netconf and fail if that is not possible.
 199     Open_ODL_Netconf_Connection
 200
 201 name2_name3_name4_In_Running_Config_After_Session_Failure
 202     [Documentation]    Check that the 3 subelements are now present in the running configuration.
 203     ${reply}=    Load_And_Send_Message    merge-multiple-check
 204     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${reply}    <name>name2</name>
 205     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${reply}    <name>name3</name>
 206     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${reply}    <name>name4</name>
 207
 208 Edit_Multiple_Modules_Merge
 209     [Documentation]    Add another subelement named "test" to the element and check the reply.
 210     Perform_Test    merge-multiple-edit
 211
 212 Commit_Multiple_Modules_Merge_Edit
 213     [Documentation]    Commit the addition of the "test" subelement and check the reply.
 214     Perform_Test    merge-multiple-edit-commit
 215
 216 Check_Multiple_Modules_Merge_Edit
 217     [Documentation]    Check that the "test" subelement exists and has correct value for "port" subelement.
 218     ${reply}=    Load_And_Send_Message    merge-multiple-edit-check
 219     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${reply}    <port xmlns="urn:opendaylight:params:xml:ns:yang:controller:md:sal:connector:netconf">2022</port>
 220
 221 Update_Multiple_Modules_Merge
 222     [Documentation]    Update the value of the "port" subelement of the "test" subelement and check the reply.
 223     Perform_Test    merge-multiple-update
 224
 225 Commit_Multiple_Modules_Merge_Update
 226     [Documentation]    Commit the update and check the reply.
 227     Perform_Test    merge-multiple-update-commit
 228
 229 Check_Multiple_Modules_Merge_Update
 230     [Documentation]    Check that the value of the "port" was really updated.
 231     ${reply}=    Load_And_Send_Message    merge-multiple-update-check
 232     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${reply}    <port xmlns="urn:opendaylight:params:xml:ns:yang:controller:md:sal:connector:netconf">3000</port>
 233
 234 Replace_Multiple_Modules_Merge
 235     [Documentation]    Replace the content of the "test" with another completely different and check the reply.
 236     Perform_Test    merge-multiple-replace
 237
 238 Commit_Multiple_Modules_Merge_Replace
 239     [Documentation]    Commit the replace and check the reply.
 240     Perform_Test    merge-multiple-replace-commit
 241
 242 Check_Multiple_Modules_Merge_Replace
 243     [Documentation]    Check that the new content is there and the old content is gone.
 244     ${reply}=    Load_And_Send_Message    merge-multiple-replace-check
 245     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${reply}    <name>test</name>
 246     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${reply}    <address xmlns="urn:opendaylight:params:xml:ns:yang:controller:md:sal:connector:netconf">10.194.132.42</address>
 247     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${reply}    <tcp-only xmlns="urn:opendaylight:params:xml:ns:yang:controller:md:sal:connector:netconf">false</tcp-only>
 248     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${reply}    <port xmlns="urn:opendaylight:params:xml:ns:yang:controller:md:sal:connector:netconf">4000</port>
 249     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${reply}    <password xmlns="urn:opendaylight:params:xml:ns:yang:controller:md:sal:connector:netconf">admin</password>
 250     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${reply}    <username xmlns="urn:opendaylight:params:xml:ns:yang:controller:md:sal:connector:netconf">admin</username>
 251     BuiltIn.Should_Not_Contain    ${reply}    <name>global-event-executor</name>
 252     BuiltIn.Should_Not_Contain    ${reply}    <name>binding-osgi-broker</name>
 253     BuiltIn.Should_Not_Contain    ${reply}    <name>dom-broker</name>
 254     BuiltIn.Should_Not_Contain    ${reply}    <name>global-netconf-dispatcher</name>
 255     BuiltIn.Should_Not_Contain    ${reply}    <name>global-netconf-processing-executor</name>
 256
 257 Remove_Multiple_Modules
 258     [Documentation]    Remove the testing "module" element and all its subelements and check the reply.
 259     Perform_Test    merge-multiple-remove
 260
 261 Commit_Multiple_Modules_Removal
 262     [Documentation]    Commit the removal and check the reply.
 263     Perform_Test    merge-multiple-remove-commit
 264
 265 Delete_Not_Existing_Module
 266     [Documentation]    Attempt to delete the "module" element again and check that it fails with the correct error.
 267     Perform_Test    delete-not-existing
 268
 269 Commit_Delete_Not_Existing_Module
 270     [Documentation]    Attempt to commit and check the reply.
 271     Test_Commit_With_No_Transactions
 272     [Teardown]    Utils.Report_Failure_Due_To_Bug    4455
 273
 274 Remove_Not_Existing_Module
 275     [Documentation]    Attempt to remove the "module" element again and check that the operation is "silently ignored".
 276     Perform_Test    remove-not-existing
 277
 278 Commit_Remove_Not_Existing_Module
 279     [Documentation]    Attempt to commit and check the reply.
 280     Perform_Test    remove-not-existing-commit
 281
 282 Close_Session
 283     [Documentation]    Close the session and check that it was closed properly.
 284     Perform_Test    close-session
 285
 286 *** Keywords ***
 287 Get_Data
 288     [Arguments]    ${name}
 289     [Documentation]    Load the specified data from the data directory and return it.
 290     ${data}=    OperatingSystem.Get_File    ${datadir}${/}${name}.${dataext}
 291     [Return]    ${data}
 292
 293 Create_ODL_Netconf_Connection
 294     [Arguments]    ${host}=${CONTROLLER}    ${port}=${ODL_NETCONF_PORT}    ${user}=${ODL_NETCONF_USER}    ${password}=${ODL_NETCONF_PASSWORD}
 295     [Documentation]    Open a netconf connecion to the given machine.
 296     # The "-s netconf" flag (see the "SSHLibrary.Write" line below)    is not
 297     # supported by SSHLibrary, therefore we need to use this elaborate and
 298     # pretty tricky way to connect to the ODL Netconf port.
 299     # TODO: Extract into NetconfKeywords as there are other tests that are
 300     #    going to need to use this operation (Netconf Performance and Scaling
 301     #    comes to my mind now as one of the things tested is the performance
 302     #    of the direct netconf connection.
 303     # TODO: Make this keyword return a dictionary object with all the
 304     #    data about the prepared connection neatly packaged. Make all
 305     #    the other keywords handling the connection accept such an
 306     #    object and pull the data out of it rather than relying on
 307     #    global variables. This will allow for tracking more Netconf
 308     #    connections, increasing utility.
 309     ${control}=    SSHLibrary.Open_Connection    ${host}    prompt=${ODL_SYSTEM_PROMPT}    timeout=10s
 310     Utils.Flexible_Controller_Login
 311     BuiltIn.Set_Suite_Variable    ${ssh_control}    ${control}
 312     ${netconf}=    SSHLibrary.Open_Connection    ${host}    prompt=${ODL_SYSTEM_PROMPT}    timeout=10s
 313     Utils.Flexible_Controller_Login
 314     BuiltIn.Set_Suite_Variable    ${ssh_netconf}    ${netconf}
 315     BuiltIn.Set_Suite_Variable    ${ssh_port}    ${port}
 316     BuiltIn.Set_Suite_Variable    ${ssh_user}    ${user}
 317     BuiltIn.Set_Suite_Variable    ${ssh_password}    ${password}
 318
 319 Reopen_ODL_Netconf_Connection
 320     [Documentation]    Reopen a closed netconf connection.
 321     SSHLibrary.Write    sshpass -p ${ssh_password} ssh -o UserKnownHostsFile=/dev/null -o StrictHostKeyChecking=no ${ssh_user}\@127.0.0.1 -p ${ssh_port} -s netconf
 322     ${hello}=    SSHLibrary.Read_Until    ${ODL_NETCONF_PROMPT}
 323     SSHLibrary.Switch_Connection    ${ssh_control}
 324     ${pid}=    SSHLibrary.Execute_Command    ps -A | grep sshpass | cut -b 1-6
 325     BuiltIn.Set_Suite_Variable    ${ssh_netconf_pid}    ${pid}
 326     SSHLibrary.Switch_Connection    ${ssh_netconf}
 327     [Return]    ${hello}
 328
 329 Open_ODL_Netconf_Connection
 330     [Documentation]    Open a prepared netconf connecion.
 331     ${hello}=    Reopen_ODL_Netconf_Connection
 332     ${hello_message}=    Get_Data    hello
 333     Transmit_Message    ${hello_message}
 334     [Return]    ${hello}
 335
 336 Transmit_Message
 337     [Arguments]    ${message}
 338     [Documentation]    Transmit message to Netconf connection and discard the echo of the message.
 339     SSHLibrary.Write    ${message}
 340     SSHLibrary.Write    ${ODL_NETCONF_PROMPT}
 341     SSHLibrary.Read_Until    ${ODL_NETCONF_PROMPT}
 342
 343 Send_Message
 344     [Arguments]    ${message}
 345     [Documentation]    Send message to Netconf connection and get the reply.
 346     Transmit_Message    ${message}
 347     ${reply}=    SSHLibrary.Read_Until    ${ODL_NETCONF_PROMPT}
 348     [Return]    ${reply}
 349
 350 Prepare_For_Search
 351     [Arguments]    ${searched_string}
 352     [Documentation]    Prepare the specified string for searching in Netconf connection replies.
 353     ...    The string passed to this keyword is coming from a data
 354     ...    file which has different end of line conventions than
 355     ...    the actual Netconf reply. This keyword patches the string
 356     ...    to match what Netconf actually returns.
 357     ${result}=    BuiltIn.Evaluate    "\\r\\n".join("""${searched_string}""".split("\\n"))
 358     [Return]    ${result}
 359
 360 Load_And_Send_Message
 361     [Arguments]    ${name}
 362     [Documentation]    Load a message from the data file set, send it to Netconf and return the reply.
 363     ${request}=    Get_Data    ${name}-request
 364     ${reply}=    Send_Message    ${request}
 365     [Return]    ${reply}
 366
 367 Load_Expected_Reply
 368     [Arguments]    ${name}
 369     [Documentation]    Load the expected reply from the data file set and return it.
 370     ${expected_reply}=    Get_Data    ${name}-reply
 371     ${expected}=    Prepare_For_Search    ${expected_reply}
 372     [Return]    ${expected}
 373
 374 Abort_ODL_Netconf_Connection
 375     [Documentation]    Correctly close the Netconf connection and make sure it is really dead.
 376     BuiltIn.Return_From_Keyword_If    ${ssh_netconf_pid} == -1
 377     ${kill_command}=    BuiltIn.Set_Variable    kill ${ssh_netconf_pid}
 378     BuiltIn.Set_Suite_Variable    ${ssh_netconf_pid}    -1
 379     SSHLibrary.Switch_Connection    ${ssh_control}
 380     SSHLibrary.Write    ${kill_command}
 381     SSHLibrary.Read_Until_Prompt
 382     SSHLibrary.Switch_Connection    ${ssh_netconf}
 383     SSHLibrary.Read_Until_Prompt
 384
 385 Close_ODL_Netconf_Connection_Gracefully
 386     Perform_Test    close-session
 387     Abort_ODL_Netconf_Connection
 388
 389 Setup_Everything
 390     [Documentation]    Setup resources and create session for Restconf checking.
 391     SetupUtils.Setup_Utils_For_Setup_And_Teardown
 392     RequestsLibrary.Create_Session    config    http://${CONTROLLER}:${RESTCONFPORT}${CONFIG_API}    auth=${AUTH}
 393
 394 Teardown_Everything
 395     [Documentation]    Close the Netconf connection and destroy all sessions in the requests library.
 396     Abort_ODL_Netconf_Connection
 397     RequestsLibrary.Delete_All_Sessions
 398
 399 Check_Test_Objects_Not_Present_In_Config
 400     [Arguments]    ${name}
 401     [Documentation]    Use dataset with the specified name to get the configuration and check that none of our test objects are there.
 402     ${reply}=    Load_And_Send_Message    ${name}
 403     BuiltIn.Should_Not_Contain    ${reply}    <name>name0</name>
 404     BuiltIn.Should_Not_Contain    ${reply}    <name>name1</name>
 405     BuiltIn.Should_Not_Contain    ${reply}    <name>name2</name>
 406     BuiltIn.Should_Not_Contain    ${reply}    <name>name3</name>
 407     BuiltIn.Should_Not_Contain    ${reply}    <name>name4</name>
 408
 409 Perform_Test
 410     [Arguments]    ${name}
 411     [Documentation]    Load and send the request from the dataset and compare the returned reply to the one stored in the dataset.
 412     ${actual}=    Load_And_Send_Message    ${name}
 413     ${expected}=    Load_Expected_Reply    ${name}
 414     ${newline}=    BuiltIn.Evaluate    "\\r\\n"
 415     BuiltIn.Should_Be_Equal    ${newline}${expected}${ODL_NETCONF_PROMPT}    ${actual}
 416     [Return]    ${actual}
 417
 418 Send_And_Check
 419     [Arguments]    ${name}    ${expected}
 420     ${actual}=    Load_And_Send_Message    ${name}
 421     BuiltIn.Should_Be_Equal    ${expected}    ${actual}
 422
 423 Test_Commit_With_No_Transactions
 424     [Documentation]    Issue a "commit" RPC request and check that it fails with "No current transactions" error.
 425     ${reply}=    Load_And_Send_Message    commit-no-transaction
 426     ${expected}=    Load_Expected_Reply    commit-no-transaction
 427     BuiltIn.Should_Contain    ${reply}    ${expected}